If you’ve ever wondered what it really takes to show up when someone searches for what you offer, you’re not alone. Google’s ranking system is famously secretive, and the advice floating around online can be confusing, contradictory, and full of jargon.
So when the research team at Zyppy Signal asked 131 SEO experts to score more than 100 possible Google ranking factors, we paid attention. The good news? The top answers are far less technical than you’d expect, and most of them are things a small business or non-profit can act on today.
Here’s what the experts agree matters most, translated into plain English.
1. Answer What People Are Actually Looking For
The number one factor, named a top-three priority by 57% of the experts, was relevance. In simple terms: does your page give people what they came for?
If someone searches “food pantry hours near me,” they want hours and an address, not a long mission statement. If they search “emergency plumber,” they want a phone number they can tap. One expert put it bluntly: a page can be technically perfect, but if it answers a different question than the one asked, it won’t help.
Try this: Look at your top pages and ask, “What would someone searching for this want to know first?” Put that answer at the top.
2. Get Mentioned by People Your Community Trusts
Links from other websites to yours (called backlinks) came in second, chosen by about 55% of experts. Despite years of people predicting their death, links from trusted, relevant sources still carry real weight.
For you, that means local connections: your chamber of commerce, community partners, sponsors, local news, or organizations you collaborate with. Experts also stressed that links people actually click matter far more than sheer numbers, and spammy links can work against you.
Try this: Make sure the partners, sponsors, and organizations you work with link back to your website.
3. Original Beats Generic
Content quality ranked third, and the experts placed a premium on original, first-hand material: your own photos, your own stories, your own results and local knowledge. Things no one else can copy.
What about AI? Experts weren’t against it, but they were wary of using it to mass-produce generic content with little added value. Think of AI as a helpful assistant, not a replacement for your voice and expertise. (If you missed it, our recent post explains what AI really is and what it can’t do.)
Try this: Replace stock photos with real ones of your team, your space, or your events.
4. Be a Name People Know and Trust
Authority, trust, and brand signals all landed in the top six. That includes how much people search for your business by name, and your overall online reputation.
This is where small organizations can shine. Genuine reviews, a complete and active Google Business Profile, and consistent contact information across the web all build trust. We covered why your Google Business Profile reviews matter more than ever late last year, and this survey backs it up.
5. Make It Easy for Visitors to Get Things Done
Experts also pointed out that Google pays attention to how people behave. If visitors click your result and quickly head back to the search results, that’s a bad sign. If they find what they need, that’s a good one.
Mobile-friendliness was highlighted as important here. Website speed was more debated, with some experts calling it a smaller factor than people think. Our take: speed won’t win the race by itself, but a painfully slow site can lose it. (Here’s why speed still matters.)
What You Can Stop Worrying About
Here’s the reassuring part. Meta descriptions, the short summaries under your page title in search results, were rated near the bottom of the list, with most experts believing they have no direct effect on rankings. Technical SEO was described as the foundation: it can hold you back if it’s broken, but it won’t lift weak content on its own.
No secret tricks, no magic settings. Mostly, it’s about being genuinely helpful, genuinely known, and easy to use.
The Bottom Line
After surveying over 100 factors, the experts’ message was refreshingly simple: help people find answers, earn trust in your community, share what’s uniquely yours, and make your website easy to use. You don’t need to be an SEO expert to do that.
Not sure where your website stands?
At EC IT Solutions, we help small businesses and non-profits make smart, simple technology decisions, with no jargon and no pressure.
💻 Let’s work together → schedule a call with us noww.





